Remembering a life

Arthur James Mitchell

February 14, 1942 – October 19, 2026

Memorial portrait of Arthur James Mitchell

A life in Lancaster County

Arthur James Mitchell

February 14, 1942 – October 19, 2026

A patient teacher, devoted father, and lifelong gardener, Arthur filled his days with good books, strong coffee, and the people he loved.

Arthur James Mitchell, 84, of Lancaster, passed away peacefully on October 19, 2026, surrounded by his family. He was born in Lititz to Harold and Beatrice Mitchell and made Lancaster County his home throughout a life shaped by curiosity and kindness.

For thirty-one years, Arthur taught history at McCaskey High School. Former students remember how he made the past feel close and human. At home, he was happiest tending his tomatoes, restoring old radios, or taking the long way around the block with his wife, Ellen.

Arthur is survived by Ellen, his wife of 58 years; children David and Laura; five grandchildren; and his sister, Ruth. His family will remember his steady humor, open door, and quiet belief that there was always room for one more at the table.

A gesture of remembrance

Send flowers

To send a floral tribute to the family or service, choose a local florist you trust.

Visit a florist

Leave a word for the family

Share a remembrance.

A story, a kind thought, or simply a name. Your words can bring comfort in the days ahead.

Messages shared

“Mr. Mitchell made every student feel that their questions mattered. I carry that with me still.”

Margaret Lewis · October 20, 2026

“Thank you for the stories, Dad. We will keep your garden growing.”

Daniel Mitchell · October 20, 2026

Write in the guestbook

Your message will reach our care team, and we’ll help it find its way to the family.

The Whitcomb family is here to help

We’re with you.

Questions about the service or need help connecting with the family? Call us any time.

Call (717) 555-0148Available 24 hours
Available 24 hoursCall 24/7 · (717) 555-0148